VS

Fiat Ducato vs Toyota Proace Transporter – Which model is better for everyday use?

Compare performance, boot capacity, efficiency and price at a glance.
Find out which car is the better choice for you – Fiat Ducato or Toyota Proace Transporter?

The Ultimate Cargo Van Showdown: Fiat Ducato vs Toyota Proace Transporter

When it comes to choosing a reliable cargo van, the market presents a variety of options promising efficiency, capacity, and modern technologies. Two models at the forefront are the Fiat Ducato and the Toyota Proace Transporter. Both are giants in their respective rights, offering unique features and capabilities. This article delves into a comparison of their technical aspects and innovations to help you make an informed decision.

Performance and Power

The Fiat Ducato offers a range of engine options, from diesel to electric, with power ratings between 120 HP and 270 HP. This versatility allows for a broad spectrum of uses, from light city driving to heavy-duty tasks. Torque on the Ducato ranges from 320 Nm to 450 Nm, providing the muscle needed for demanding hauling jobs.

The Toyota Proace Transporter, however, comes with engine power ranging from 120 HP to 144 HP. Although slightly less potent than the Ducato, the Proace balances performance with economy. It delivers torque between 260 Nm and 370 Nm, ensuring solid and consistent performance for its class.

Fuel Economy and Environmental Impact

Fuel efficiency remains a critical factor for cargo vans. The Fiat Ducato has a consumption range between 7.2 to 9.3 L/100km for diesel variants and offers an impressive electric range of 430 km, targeting eco-conscious drivers.

The Toyota Proace Transporter offers a competitive advantage with diesel consumption rates from 6.6 to 7.6 L/100km, presenting a more economical choice for long-haul driving. Additionally, the electric variant offers an electric range of up to 349 km, making it a commendable choice for emission-sensitive urban environments.

Dimensions and Capacity

The Fiat Ducato boasts a length spectrum from 5413 mm to 6678 mm, a width of up to 2100 mm, and varies in height up to 2774 mm. This range ensures that there’s a model to suit differing storage and maneuverability needs. Moreover, with payload capacities reaching up to 1425 kg, the Ducato proves itself as a robust workhorse.

In comparison, the Toyota Proace Transporter is slightly more compact, with lengths from 4980 mm to 5330 mm and a maximum width of 1920 mm. Its height tops out at around 1935 mm, offering a significant advantage in tight urban settings. The Proace's payload capabilities range up to 1496 kg, showcasing its suitability for diverse cargo solutions.

Technological Features and Comfort

Both models are equipped with modern transmission systems, offering manual, automatic, and reduction gearboxes to cater to different driving preferences. The Ducato comes with a four-door setup, ideal for easy access to storage, while the Proace Transporter provides flexibility with four and five-door options, catering to varying crew transport needs.

On the front of technological innovation, both vehicles strive for efficiency and eco-friendliness. The Ducato leads with CO2 emission ratings as low as 148 g/km for certain models, while the Proace also focuses on reducing its environmental impact with a zero-emission electric variant.

Conclusion: Which Van Comes Out on Top?

The choice between the Fiat Ducato and Toyota Proace Transporter largely depends on specific business needs. While the Ducato offers higher power options and a broader range of capacities, the Proace stands out with its fuel efficiency and nimbleness, especially in urban settings.

Ultimately, both vehicles present excellent options with their innovative engineering, ensuring reliability and performance for any commercial needs. The decision may come down to a balance between power and economy, depending on what drives your business on the road.

Here’s where it gets real: The technical differences in detail

Costs and Efficiency:

Price and efficiency are often the first things buyers look at. Here it becomes clear which model has the long-term edge – whether at the pump, the plug, or in purchase price.

Toyota Proace Transporter has a hardly perceptible advantage in terms of price – it starts at 31600 £, while the Fiat Ducato costs 34300 £. That’s a price difference of around 2688 £.

Fuel consumption also shows a difference: Toyota Proace Transporter manages with 6.40 L and is therefore to a small extent more efficient than the Fiat Ducato with 7.50 L. The difference is about 1.10 L per 100 km.

As for range, the Fiat Ducato performs somewhat better – achieving up to 430 km, about 81 km more than the Toyota Proace Transporter.

Engine and Performance:

Power, torque and acceleration are the classic benchmarks for car enthusiasts – and here, some clear differences start to show.

When it comes to engine power, the Fiat Ducato has a decisively edge – offering 270 HP compared to 150 HP. That’s roughly 120 HP more horsepower.

In terms of top speed, the Toyota Proace Transporter performs hardly perceptible better – reaching 170 km/h, while the Fiat Ducato tops out at 165 km/h. The difference is around 5 km/h.

There’s also a difference in torque: Fiat Ducato pulls slightly stronger with 450 Nm compared to 370 Nm. That’s about 80 Nm difference.

Space and Everyday Use:

Cabin size, boot volume and payload all play a role in everyday practicality. Here, comfort and flexibility make the difference.

Seats: Toyota Proace Transporter offers significantly more seating capacity – 6 vs 3.

In curb weight, Toyota Proace Transporter is noticeable lighter – 1656 kg compared to 2125 kg. The difference is around 469 kg.

In maximum load capacity, the Fiat Ducato performs significantly better – up to 17000 L, which is about 10400 L more than the Toyota Proace Transporter.

When it comes to payload, Fiat Ducato clearly perceptible takes the win – 2020 kg compared to 1323 kg. That’s a difference of about 697 kg.

Who wins the race?

The Fiat Ducato proves to be wins the duel decisively and therefore becomes our DriveDuel Champion!
Fiat Ducato is the better all-rounder in this comparison.

from about £34,300

Fiat Ducato

  • Engine Type : Diesel, Electric
  • Transmission : Manuel, Automatic
  • Drive Type : Front-Wheel Drive
  • Power HP : 120 - 270 HP
  • Consumption L/100km : 7.5 - 9 L
  • Electric Range : 430 km
details

Fiat Ducato

The Fiat Ducato is a versatile vehicle that has remained popular among business owners and adventurers alike. With its spacious interior and practical design, it is ideal for transporting goods or converting into a camper van for travel enthusiasts. Its robust performance and reliability have solidified its reputation as a staple in the commercial van market.

details

Toyota Proace Transporter

The Toyota Proace Transporter is a versatile vehicle designed to meet a variety of professional needs. With a focus on practicality, it offers a spacious interior and a flexible layout that can be adapted for both goods and passenger transport. Its efficient design and reliable performance make it a popular choice for businesses looking for a dependable workhorse.

details

Similar Comparisons

Fiat Ducato
Peugeot Boxer
VS
In the competitive world of commercial vans, the Fiat Ducato and Peugeot Boxer stand out for their practicality and efficiency. Both models offer spacious interiors and robust performance, making them ideal choices for businesses requiring reliable transport. However, while the Ducato boasts a slight edge in fuel economy, the Boxer impresses with its user-friendly technology and driving comfort, ensuring that both vehicles cater to a variety of professional needs.
Citroen Jumper
Fiat Ducato
VS
In the competitive segment of commercial vans, the Citroën Jumper and Fiat Ducato stand out as top contenders, offering robust performance and impressive cargo capacity. With a focus on comfort and usability, both models feature spacious interiors and advanced technology, catering to the needs of businesses and tradespeople alike. However, the Jumper's unique styling and additional customization options may appeal to those looking for a distinct edge over the Ducato in both aesthetics and practicality.
Fiat Ducato
Toyota Proace Transporter

Costs and Consumption
Price
34300 - 57800 £
Price
31600 - 51000 £
Consumption L/100km
7.5 - 9 L
Consumption L/100km
6.4 - 6.7 L
Consumption kWh/100km
-
Consumption kWh/100km
23.8 - 23.9 kWh
Electric Range
430 km
Electric Range
221 - 349 km
Battery Capacity
-
Battery Capacity
-
co2
0 - 233 g/km
co2
0 - 177 g/km
Fuel tank capacity
90 L
Fuel tank capacity
69 L

Dimensions and Body
Body Type
Cargo Van
Body Type
Cargo Van
Seats
3
Seats
3 - 6
Doors
4
Doors
4 - 5
Curb weight
2125 - 2940 kg
Curb weight
1656 - 2100 kg
Trunk capacity
-
Trunk capacity
-
Length
5413 - 6678 mm
Length
4980 - 5330 mm
Width
2050 - 2100 mm
Width
1920 mm
Height
2254 - 2774 mm
Height
1895 - 1935 mm
Max trunk capacity
10000 - 17000 L
Max trunk capacity
3200 - 6600 L
Payload
560 - 2020 kg
Payload
955 - 1323 kg

Engine and Performance
Engine Type
Diesel, Electric
Engine Type
Electric, Diesel
Transmission
Manuel, Automatic
Transmission
Automatic, Manuel
Transmission Detail
Manual Gearbox, Automatic Gearbox, Reduction Gearbox
Transmission Detail
Reduction Gearbox, Manual Gearbox, Automatic Gearbox
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
Power HP
120 - 270 HP
Power HP
120 - 150 HP
Acceleration 0-100km/h
-
Acceleration 0-100km/h
12.1 - 13.3 s
Max Speed
90 - 165 km/h
Max Speed
130 - 170 km/h
Torque
320 - 450 Nm
Torque
260 - 370 Nm
Number of Cylinders
4
Number of Cylinders
4
Power kW
88 - 200 kW
Power kW
88 - 110 kW
Engine capacity
2184 cm3
Engine capacity
1499 - 2184 cm3

General
Model Year
2023 - 2025
Model Year
2024 - 2025
CO2 Efficiency Class
G, A
CO2 Efficiency Class
A
Brand
Fiat
Brand
Toyota

Similar Comparisons

Fiat Ducato
VW Crafter
VS
When comparing the Fiat Ducato and the VW Crafter, both models shine in the versatile van segment, but they each have distinct advantages. The Ducato stands out for its impressive cargo capacity and fuel efficiency, making it a favorite for businesses focused on practicality. On the other hand, the Crafter boasts a more refined interior and a range of advanced technology options, appealing to those who prioritize comfort and connectivity during long drives.
Vauxhall Vivaro
Toyota Proace Transporter
VS
Fiat Ducato
Toyota Proace Max
VS
In the realm of versatile vans, the Fiat Ducato and Toyota Proace offer compelling options for both commercial and recreational use. The Fiat Ducato stands out with its robust load capacity and a broad range of customizable configurations, catering to various business needs. Meanwhile, the Toyota Proace impresses with its reliability and efficiency, boasting advanced safety features and a comfortable driving experience, making it a strong contender for those seeking both utility and peace of mind.
Fiat Ducato
Vauxhall Movano
VS
In the competitive segment of compact cars, the Fiat 500 and the Opel Astra present unique offerings that cater to different consumer preferences. The Fiat 500, with its iconic design and urban-friendly dimensions, appeals to those seeking a stylish city car, while the Opel Astra boasts a more spacious interior and advanced technology features, making it an excellent choice for families and longer journeys. Ultimately, the decision between the two will hinge on individual priorities, whether it be aesthetics and maneuverability or practicality and comfort.
Fiat Ducato
Mercedes Sprinter Transporter
VS
In the battle of commercial vans, the Fiat Ducato and Mercedes Sprinter Transporter stand out for their unique strengths. The Ducato impresses with its competitive pricing and flexible cargo space, making it a favorite among small business owners. Meanwhile, the Sprinter offers advanced technology and superior interior comfort, appealing to those who prioritize luxury alongside functionality in their transport solutions.
Fiat Ducato
Renault Master Bus
VS
Fiat Ducato
Fiat Scudo
VS
Fiat Ducato
Ford Transit Custom Camper
VS
What drive types are available for the Fiat Ducato?

The Fiat Ducato is available as Front-Wheel Drive.

The prices and data displayed are estimates based on German list prices and may vary by country. This information is not legally binding.