VS

BMW X1 vs Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake – Differences & prices compared

Compare performance, boot capacity, efficiency and price at a glance.
Find out which car is the better choice for you – BMW X1 or Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake?

Here’s where it gets real: The technical differences in detail

Costs and Efficiency:

When it comes to price and running costs, the biggest differences usually appear. This is often where you see which car fits your budget better in the long run.

Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake has a hardly perceptible advantage in terms of price – it starts at 37700 £, while the BMW X1 costs 38200 £. That’s a price difference of around 494 £.

Fuel consumption also shows a difference: BMW X1 manages with 0.80 L and is therefore decisively more efficient than the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake with 2.40 L. The difference is about 1.60 L per 100 km.

As for range, the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake performs minimal better – achieving up to 84 km, about 1 km more than the BMW X1.

Engine and Performance:

Power, torque and acceleration say a lot about how a car feels on the road. This is where you see which model delivers more driving dynamics.

When it comes to engine power, the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake has a noticeable edge – offering 421 HP compared to 326 HP. That’s roughly 95 HP more horsepower.

In acceleration from 0 to 100 km/h, the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake is clearly perceptible quicker – completing the sprint in 4.10 s, while the BMW X1 takes 5.40 s. That’s about 1.30 s faster.

In terms of top speed, the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake performs barely noticeable better – reaching 270 km/h, while the BMW X1 tops out at 250 km/h. The difference is around 20 km/h.

There’s also a difference in torque: Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake pulls slight stronger with 500 Nm compared to 477 Nm. That’s about 23 Nm difference.

Space and Everyday Use:

Whether family car or daily driver – which one offers more room, flexibility and comfort?

Both vehicles offer seating for 5 people.

In curb weight, Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake is barely noticeable lighter – 1530 kg compared to 1575 kg. The difference is around 45 kg.

In terms of boot space, the BMW X1 offers minimal more room – 540 L compared to 505 L. That’s a difference of about 35 L.

In maximum load capacity, the BMW X1 performs to a small extent better – up to 1600 L, which is about 230 L more than the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake.

When it comes to payload, Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake slight takes the win – 520 kg compared to 500 kg. That’s a difference of about 20 kg.

Who comes out on top?

Overall, the BMW X1 shows itself to be is largely superior and secures the title of DriveDuel Champion.
It convinces with the more balanced overall package and proves to be the more versatile choice for everyday use.

from about £38,200
P90479957_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09

BMW X1

  • Engine Type : Diesel MHEV, Petrol MHEV, Plugin Hybrid, Petrol, Diesel
  • Transmission : Automatic
  • Drive Type : Front-Wheel Drive, All-Wheel Drive
  • Power HP : 136 - 326 HP
  • Consumption L/100km : 0.8 - 7.7 L
  • Electric Range : 83 km
details

BMW X1

3.7 (3)
rate

The new BMW X1 effortlessly blends sporty elegance with practical functionality, making it a standout choice in the compact SUV segment. Inside, the sophisticated cabin design is complemented by high-quality materials and cutting-edge technology, creating a welcoming and advanced driving environment. On the road, the vehicle's agile handling and responsive performance promise an engaging driving experience, whether navigating urban streets or embarking on longer journeys.

details
P90479957_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09 @ press.bmwgroup.com
P90479906_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09 @ press.bmwgroup.com
P90479918_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09 @ press.bmwgroup.com
P90479901_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09 @ press.bmwgroup.com
P90479947_highRes_bmw-x1-xdrive-23i-09 @ press.bmwgroup.com

Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake

5 (1)
rate

The Mercedes-Benz CLA Shooting Brake artfully combines the sleek aesthetics of a coupé with the practicality of an estate. Its interior boasts luxurious materials and cutting-edge technology, providing a sophisticated driving experience. With a focus on style and functionality, this model is designed to appeal to both the modern family and the discerning individual.

details
19C0120_001 @ group-media.mercedes-benz.com
19C0120_008 @ group-media.mercedes-benz.com
19C0120_058 @ group-media.mercedes-benz.com
19C0111_015 @ group-media.mercedes-benz.com
19C0582_014 @ group-media.mercedes-benz.com

Similar Comparisons

BMW 2 Series Active Tourer
BMW X1
VS
The BMW 2 Series Active Tourer is the clever, family-focused MPV that swaps SUV posturing for genuinely useful space and a lower, car‑like ride, while the BMW X1 dresses up as a compact SUV with higher seating, tougher styling and a bit more composure on rutted roads. Pick the 2 Series for easy access, clever packaging and relaxed refinement; choose the X1 if you want presence, a firmer ride and the kind of image that makes neighbours do a double‑take.
Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake
Mercedes GLA
VS
In the battle between the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake and the Mercedes GLA, both models showcase the brand's signature blend of luxury and performance. The CLA Shooting Brake offers a sleek, coupe-like silhouette with added practicality, while the GLA boasts a more robust stance and superior off-road capabilities. Ultimately, your choice may come down to whether you prioritize style or versatility in your driving experience.
BMW X1
Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake
X1
CLA Shooting Brake

Costs and Consumption
Price
38200 - 55500 £
Price
37700 - 74700 £
Consumption L/100km
0.8 - 7.7 L
Consumption L/100km
2.4 - 9.1 L
Consumption kWh/100km
-
Consumption kWh/100km
-
Electric Range
83 km
Electric Range
84 km
Battery Capacity
14.20 kWh
Battery Capacity
12.90 kWh
co2
17 - 175 g/km
co2
55 - 206 g/km
Fuel tank capacity
47 - 54 L
Fuel tank capacity
35 - 51 L

Dimensions and Body
Body Type
SUV
Body Type
Estate
Seats
5
Seats
5
Doors
5
Doors
5
Curb weight
1575 - 1935 kg
Curb weight
1530 - 1775 kg
Trunk capacity
490 - 540 L
Trunk capacity
445 - 505 L
Length
4500 - 4505 mm
Length
4692 - 4695 mm
Width
1845 mm
Width
1834 - 1857 mm
Height
1622 - 1642 mm
Height
1405 - 1433 mm
Max trunk capacity
1495 - 1600 L
Max trunk capacity
1310 - 1370 L
Payload
490 - 500 kg
Payload
460 - 520 kg

Engine and Performance
Engine Type
Diesel MHEV, Petrol MHEV, Plugin Hybrid, Petrol, Diesel
Engine Type
Plugin Hybrid, Petrol MHEV, Diesel, Petrol
Transmission
Automatic
Transmission
Automatic
Transmission Detail
Dual-Clutch Automatic
Transmission Detail
Dual-Clutch Automatic
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive, All-Wheel Drive
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive, All-Wheel Drive
Power HP
136 - 326 HP
Power HP
116 - 421 HP
Acceleration 0-100km/h
5.4 - 9.2 s
Acceleration 0-100km/h
4.1 - 10.1 s
Max Speed
190 - 250 km/h
Max Speed
203 - 270 km/h
Torque
230 - 477 Nm
Torque
230 - 500 Nm
Number of Cylinders
3 - 4
Number of Cylinders
4
Power kW
100 - 240 kW
Power kW
85 - 310 kW
Engine capacity
1499 - 1998 cm3
Engine capacity
1332 - 1991 cm3

General
Model Year
2023 - 2025
Model Year
2024 - 2025
CO2 Efficiency Class
D, E, B, F
CO2 Efficiency Class
B, D, E, G
Brand
BMW
Brand
Mercedes-Benz

Similar Comparisons

BMW 3 Series Touring
BMW X1
VS
In the realm of compact luxury vehicles, the BMW 3er Touring and BMW X1 present distinct yet appealing choices for discerning drivers. The 3er Touring showcases a sporty dynamics and elegant design, catering to those who appreciate a performance-oriented driving experience coupled with ample cargo space. On the other hand, the X1 stands out with its elevated stance and versatile interior, making it an ideal option for customers seeking practicality without compromising on style.
BMW X1
BYD Seal U
VS
The BMW X1 and BYD Seal U represent the latest offerings in the competitive compact SUV segment, each appealing to distinctive tastes. The BMW X1 impresses with its refined aesthetics and traditional luxury feel, powered by a performance-focused, efficient engine lineup. On the other hand, the BYD Seal U distinguishes itself with cutting-edge electric mobility technology, offering a greener alternative complemented by advanced features at a competitive price point.
BMW X1
CUPRA Terramar
VS
In the competitive crossover segment, the BMW X1 stands out with its premium interior and agile handling, delivering an engaging driving experience that enthusiasts appreciate. On the other hand, the CUPRA Terramar impresses with its bold design and sporty performance, appealing to those who crave a distinctive flair and robust engine options. Both models cater to different tastes, but they share a commitment to combining practicality with exhilarating driving dynamics.
BMW 3 Series Touring
Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake
VS
In the competitive world of premium wagons, the BMW 3er Touring and the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake stand out with their distinctive characters and performance attributes. The 3er Touring offers a perfect blend of sporty handling and practicality, making it an ideal choice for driving enthusiasts who need versatility, while the CLA Shooting Brake impresses with its sleek design and luxurious finishes, catering to a more style-conscious audience. Ultimately, both vehicles provide an exhilarating driving experience, but your choice may come down to whether you prioritize dynamic performance or elegant aesthetics.
BMW X1
Land Rover Range Rover Evoque
VS
BMW X1
Toyota RAV4
VS
In the competitive crossover segment, the BMW X1 stands out with its luxurious interior and sporty handling, appealing to drivers seeking a premium experience. In contrast, the Toyota RAV4 excels in practicality and reliability, offering ample cargo space and advanced safety features that cater to families and adventurous types alike. Ultimately, the choice between these two models boils down to personal preferences, with the X1 prioritizing driving dynamics and the RAV4 focusing on functionality and value.
Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake
Volvo V60
VS
In the battle of stylish practicality, the Mercedes CLA Shooting Brake and Volvo V60 present two distinct philosophies for discerning drivers. The CLA impresses with its sleek design and sporty driving dynamics, making it a standout for those who prioritize aesthetics and performance. In contrast, the Volvo V60 offers a more spacious interior and a strong emphasis on safety and comfort, appealing to families and those seeking a more laid-back driving experience.
BMW X1
Ford Kuga
VS
In a head-to-head comparison between the BMW X1 and Ford Kuga, the BMW takes the edge with its premium interior quality and dynamic driving experience. However, the Ford Kuga shines with its spacious cabin and advanced safety features, catering to families seeking practicality. Ultimately, choosing between these two contenders boils down to whether you prioritize luxury or versatility in your compact SUV.
Is the BMW X1 offered with different drivetrains?

The BMW X1 is offered with Front-Wheel Drive or All-Wheel Drive.

The prices and data displayed are estimates based on German list prices and may vary by country. This information is not legally binding.