Compare performance (326 HP vs 218 HP), boot space and price (38,200 £ vs 34,600 £ ) at a glance. Find out which car is the better choice for you – BMW X1 or Renault Scénic?
In the dynamic world of SUVs, two competitors, the BMW X1 and the Renault Scénic, bring distinct flavors of performance, style, and innovation. As prospective buyers evaluate their next vehicle purchase, these models stand out for their compelling offerings. Let's dive into a head-to-head comparison, focusing on their technical specifications and innovations for the 2023/2024 models.
The BMW X1 offers a versatile lineup with multiple engine types including diesel, petrol, mild hybrids (MHEV), and a plug-in hybrid variant. The power output ranges from 136 HP to an impressive 326 HP. This diversity allows the X1 to cater to different driving needs, with the flexibility of front-wheel or all-wheel drive options. In terms of acceleration, the BMW X1 hits 0-100 km/h as quick as an impressive 5.4 seconds, depending on the engine choice.
On the other hand, the Renault Scénic stays true to the electric future with its all-electric powertrain. Offering two power levels—170 HP and 220 HP—the Scénic prioritizes eco-friendliness with a CO2 emission rate of zero. It provides competitive acceleration, going from 0-100 km/h in just 7.9 seconds with its more powerful engine variant.
When it comes to fuel efficiency, the BMW X1's hybrid versions are particularly noteworthy. The plug-in hybrid model boasts an electric range of 83 km with a fuel consumption of as low as 0.8 L/100km, highlighting its efficiency in urban settings. The conventional engines range from an economic 4.6 L/100km to a spirited 7.7 L/100km, based on the powertrain and driving conditions.
In contrast, the Renault Scénic is purely electric, offering an impressive range that spans from 420 km to 598 km, making it a reliable option for longer journeys. Its energy consumption between 16.7 kWh to 17.6 kWh per 100 km positions it well within the segment of efficient electric vehicles, complemented by its eco-conscious CO2 efficiency class of 'A'.
Both vehicles exude their brand's design ethos while satisfying the practical needs of SUV buyers. The BMW X1 embodies a sleek profile with a length of up to 4505 mm, a width of 1845 mm, and a height ranging from 1622 mm to 1642 mm, maintaining the quintessential BMW athletic stance. Its trunk capacity varies between 490 and 540 liters, aligning with the needs of families or those requiring ample cargo space.
The Renault Scénic, slightly shorter in length at 4470 mm but wider at 1864 mm, offers a spacious interior, especially for an electric vehicle. Its trunk space stands at 545 liters, providing a bit more room than the X1. The Scénic’s design focuses on maximizing internal space while maintaining a compact exterior that facilitates urban navigation.
The technology suite in the BMW X1 is reflective of the brand's commitment to driving excellence, featuring advanced driver-assistance systems and a comprehensive infotainment interface that enhances the driving experience. It provides a blend of efficiency and performance tech aimed at optimizing each journey.
Conversely, the Renault Scénic embraces technological innovations in electric mobility, with a reduction gearbox to manage torque delivery smoothly. It features cutting-edge electric drive technology, aligning with the shift towards sustainable transport solutions.
The choice between the BMW X1 and Renault Scénic ultimately depends on individual needs and preferences. The BMW X1 stands out with its diverse engine options, powerful performance, and luxury design, appealing to those who desire flexibility and power in their SUV. Meanwhile, the Renault Scénic scores highly with its eco-friendly electric powertrain, spacious design, and advanced electric technology, catering to those who prioritize sustainability without sacrificing functionality.
Price and efficiency are key factors when choosing a car – and this is often where the real differences emerge.
Renault Scénic is a bit cheaper – starting at 34,600 £ , while the BMW X1 costs 38,200 £ . That’s a price difference of around 3,600 £.
As for electric range, the Renault Scénic offers considerably more range – reaching up to 598 km, about 517 km more than the BMW X1.
Under the bonnet, it becomes clear which model is tuned for sportiness and which one takes the lead when you hit the accelerator.
When it comes to engine power, the BMW X1 offers noticeably more power – delivering 326 HP compared to 218 HP. That’s roughly 108 HP more horsepower.
When accelerating from 0 to 100 km/h, the BMW X1 is considerably quicker – completing the sprint in 5.4 s, while the Renault Scénic takes 7.9 s. That’s about 2.5 s quicker.
Looking at top speed, the BMW X1 is visibly faster – reaching 233 km/h, while the Renault Scénic tops out at 170 km/h. The difference is around 63 km/h.
There’s also a difference in torque: the BMW X1 delivers markedly more torque with 477 Nm compared to 300 Nm. That’s about 177 Nm more.
Cabin size, boot volume and payload all play a role in everyday practicality. Here, comfort and flexibility make the difference.
Both vehicles offer seating for 5 people.
In terms of curb weight, BMW X1 is somewhat lighter – 1,575 kg compared to 1,822 kg. The difference is around 247 kg.
Looking at boot space, the Renault Scénic offers only slightly more boot space – 545 L compared to 540 L. That’s a difference of about 5 L.
For maximum load capacity, the Renault Scénic offers barely more capacity – up to 1,670 L, about 125 L more than the BMW X1.
When it comes to payload, the Renault Scénic carries marginally more – 518 kg compared to 500 kg. That’s a difference of about 18 kg.
The Renault Scénic holds a slight edge in the objective data comparison.
This result only shows which model scores more points on paper – not which of the two cars feels right for you.
The BMW X1 brings a premium feel to compact crossover life, wrapping practical space and agile handling into a tidy, upscale package. It’s ideal for buyers who want BMW driving dynamics without the bulk, offering everyday comfort and a few clever tricks to keep the commute interesting.
details
The Renault Scénic is a quietly clever family MPV that balances everyday practicality with unexpected flair, offering a roomy, flexible cabin that makes school runs and weekend escapes less of a chore. It won't dazzle like a sports car, but its composed ride, sensible tech and thoughtful storage solutions make it a superbly pragmatic choice for buyers who prefer substance with a wink.
details
Costs and Consumption |
|
|---|---|
|
Price
38,200 - 55,500 £
|
Price
34,600 - 44,000 £
|
|
Consumption L/100km
2.5 - 7.7 L/100km
|
Consumption L/100km
-
|
|
Consumption kWh/100km
-
|
Consumption kWh/100km
16.6 - 17.5 kWh/100km
|
|
Electric Range
81 km
|
Electric Range
420 - 598 km
|
|
Battery Capacity
14.2 kWh
|
Battery Capacity
-
|
|
co2
57 - 175 g/km
|
co2
0 g/km
|
|
Fuel tank capacity
47 - 54 L
|
Fuel tank capacity
-
|
Dimensions and Body |
|
|---|---|
|
Body Type
SUV
|
Body Type
SUV
|
|
Seats
5
|
Seats
5
|
|
Doors
5
|
Doors
5
|
|
Curb weight
1,575 - 1,935 kg
|
Curb weight
1,822 - 1,927 kg
|
|
Trunk capacity
490 - 540 L
|
Trunk capacity
545 L
|
|
Length
4,500 mm
|
Length
4,470 mm
|
|
Width
1,845 mm
|
Width
1,864 mm
|
|
Height
1,630 - 1,642 mm
|
Height
1,571 mm
|
|
Max trunk capacity
1,495 - 1,545 L
|
Max trunk capacity
1,670 L
|
|
Payload
490 - 500 kg
|
Payload
514 - 518 kg
|
Engine and Performance |
|
|---|---|
|
Engine Type
Diesel MHEV, Petrol MHEV, Petrol, Diesel, Plugin Hybrid
|
Engine Type
Electric
|
|
Transmission
Automatic
|
Transmission
Automatic
|
|
Transmission Detail
Dual-Clutch Automatic
|
Transmission Detail
Reduction Gearbox
|
|
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive, All-Wheel Drive
|
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
|
|
Power HP
136 - 326 HP
|
Power HP
170 - 218 HP
|
|
Acceleration 0-100km/h
5.4 - 9.2 s
|
Acceleration 0-100km/h
7.9 - 8.6 s
|
|
Max Speed
190 - 233 km/h
|
Max Speed
150 - 170 km/h
|
|
Torque
230 - 477 Nm
|
Torque
280 - 300 Nm
|
|
Number of Cylinders
3 - 4
|
Number of Cylinders
-
|
|
Power kW
100 - 240 kW
|
Power kW
125 - 160 kW
|
|
Engine capacity
1,499 - 1,998 cm3
|
Engine capacity
-
|
General |
|
|---|---|
|
Model Year
2,024 - 2,025
|
Model Year
2,025
|
|
CO2 Efficiency Class
D, E, F, B
|
CO2 Efficiency Class
A
|
|
Brand
BMW
|
Brand
Renault
|
Deutschland
France
Nederland
Great Britain
Sverige
Danmark
Suomi
Italia
Polska
España