Compare performance (180 HP vs 136 HP), boot space and price (30,900 £ vs 22,400 £ ) at a glance. Find out which car is the better choice for you – Fiat Scudo or Toyota Proace City Compact Van?
When it comes to compact cargo vans, both the Fiat Scudo and the Toyota Proace City are popular choices, blending utility with modern innovation. Each offers distinct features tailored for different user needs. Let's dive into a comprehensive comparison that highlights their technical aspects, performance capabilities, and groundbreaking innovations.
The Fiat Scudo offers a diverse range of engines, including diesel and electric variants, with horsepower options ranging from 100 to 180 HP. This Italian workhorse is available in both manual and automatic transmissions, promising versatility for different driving preferences. Fuel consumption for the diesel models hovers between 6.5 to 7.8 L/100km, which aligns with typical expectations for vehicles in this class. Electrically, it boasts an impressive range of up to 352 km, delivering a modern, green alternative.
In contrast, the Toyota Proace City provides an engine selection of electric, diesel, and petrol. The power output is slightly more streamlined compared to its Italian counterpart, spanning 102 to 136 HP. Toyota's electric variant leads in efficiency, consuming just 18.5 kWh/100km and offering a range of 337 km. Its diesel engines showcase exceptional fuel efficiency, starting at a notable 5.4 L/100km.
Design-wise, the Fiat Scudo stands out with its robust build, measuring between 4609 to 5330 mm in length, making it suitable for larger loads without compromising on maneuverability. Its payload capacity maximizes utility with a range from 842 kg to a hefty 1805 kg, catering to a wide array of business needs.
Meanwhile, the Toyota Proace City offers a more compact dimension at 4401 to 4751 mm in length, prioritizing easy urban navigation and space efficiency. This model's payload varies from 560 kg to 921 kg, balancing convenience and cargo space superbly.
If interior space and comfort are your priorities, the Fiat Scudo does not disappoint. Offering seating options for two to six passengers, it adapts well to different crew sizes, ideal for small business teams or larger family needs. Its interior height of up to 1935 mm permits a relatively spacious and comfortable working environment.
Toyota’s offering is tailored for smaller teams with seating potential for up to five passengers. The reduced dimensions of the Proace City focus on maintaining a smart, city-friendly profile without sacrificing essential internal space.
Both vans reflect a dedication to harnessing modern technological advancements. The Fiat Scudo comes equipped with innovative engineering solutions aimed at maximizing efficiency and minimizing environmental impact with a zero-emission option.
Toyota complements this with its cutting-edge electric drivetrain in the Proace City, which ensures a smooth ride and reduced environmental footprint. Its automatic transmission options are designed for ease of use, adding to the vehicle's driver-friendly experience.
The choice between the Fiat Scudo and Toyota Proace City ultimately depends on specific requirements. The Scudo stands out with its power and payload capacities, suitable for those needing larger space and flexibility. Conversely, the Proace City is tailored for urban settings, focusing on fuel efficiency and maneuverability. Whether your emphasis is on cargo space, seating, or cutting-edge green technologies, both models present viable options, catering to a spectrum of professional and personal needs.
Looking at overall running costs, both models reveal some interesting differences in everyday economy.
Toyota Proace City Compact Van is markedly cheaper – starting at 22,400 £ , while the Fiat Scudo costs 30,900 £ . That’s a price difference of around 8,553 £.
Fuel consumption also shows a difference: the Toyota Proace City Compact Van uses 5.2 L/100km and is slightly more efficient than the Fiat Scudo with 6.2 L/100km. The difference is about 1 L/100km.
In terms of energy consumption, the Toyota Proace City Compact Van is clearly more efficient: consuming 18.5 kWh/100km compared to 23.6 kWh/100km for the Fiat Scudo. That’s a difference of about 5.1 kWh/100km.
As for electric range, the Fiat Scudo offers very slightly more range – reaching up to 352 km, about 15 km more than the Toyota Proace City Compact Van.
Power, torque and acceleration are the classic benchmarks for car enthusiasts – and here, some clear differences start to show.
When it comes to engine power, the Fiat Scudo offers visibly more power – delivering 180 HP compared to 136 HP. That’s roughly 44 HP more horsepower.
When accelerating from 0 to 100 km/h, the Fiat Scudo is marginally quicker – completing the sprint in 10.5 s, while the Toyota Proace City Compact Van takes 11.1 s. That’s about 0.6 s quicker.
There’s also a difference in torque: the Fiat Scudo delivers noticeably more torque with 400 Nm compared to 300 Nm. That’s about 100 Nm more.
Whether family car or daily driver – which one offers more room, flexibility and comfort?
Seats: Fiat Scudo offers more seats – 8 vs 5.
In terms of curb weight, Toyota Proace City Compact Van is clearly lighter – 1,358 kg compared to 1,722 kg. The difference is around 364 kg.
When it comes to payload, the Fiat Scudo carries significantly more – 1,805 kg compared to 921 kg. That’s a difference of about 884 kg.
The Fiat Scudo is decisively ahead in the objective data comparison.
This result only shows which model scores more points on paper – not which of the two cars feels right for you.
The Fiat Scudo is a practical and unpretentious van that balances hardworking utility with a surprisingly polished cabin, making it a sensible choice for tradespeople and families who need space without fuss. It doesn't pretend to be flashy, but its clever packaging, sensible driving manners and affordable running costs make the Scudo a dependable partner for the daily grind and weekend projects — and it even manages to look tidy in the car park.
details
The Toyota Proace City Compact Van is a city-savvy workhorse that packs surprising practicality and smart packaging into a friendly, easy-to-drive package. It’s the kind of van that gets the job done without fuss — reliable, economical and just sensible enough to make fleet managers smile.
details
Costs and Consumption |
|
|---|---|
|
Price
30,900 - 51,300 £
|
Price
22,400 - 37,300 £
|
|
Consumption L/100km
6.2 - 7.3 L/100km
|
Consumption L/100km
5.2 - 6.6 L/100km
|
|
Consumption kWh/100km
23.6 - 24 kWh/100km
|
Consumption kWh/100km
18.5 kWh/100km
|
|
Electric Range
221 - 352 km
|
Electric Range
337 km
|
|
Battery Capacity
-
|
Battery Capacity
-
|
|
co2
0 - 187 g/km
|
co2
0 - 149 g/km
|
|
Fuel tank capacity
-
|
Fuel tank capacity
-
|
Dimensions and Body |
|
|---|---|
|
Body Type
Cargo Van, Bus
|
Body Type
Cargo Van
|
|
Seats
2 - 8
|
Seats
3 - 5
|
|
Doors
-
|
Doors
-
|
|
Curb weight
1,722 - 2,260 kg
|
Curb weight
1,358 - 1,837 kg
|
|
Trunk capacity
450 - 800 L
|
Trunk capacity
-
|
|
Length
-
|
Length
-
|
|
Width
1,920 - 2,010 mm
|
Width
1,848 mm
|
|
Height
-
|
Height
-
|
|
Max trunk capacity
-
|
Max trunk capacity
-
|
|
Payload
840 - 1,805 kg
|
Payload
560 - 921 kg
|
Engine and Performance |
|
|---|---|
|
Engine Type
Electric, Diesel
|
Engine Type
Electric, Petrol, Diesel
|
|
Transmission
Automatic, Manuel
|
Transmission
Automatic, Manuel
|
|
Transmission Detail
Reduction Gearbox, Manual Gearbox, Automatic Gearbox
|
Transmission Detail
Reduction Gearbox, Manual Gearbox, Automatic Gearbox
|
|
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
|
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
|
|
Power HP
120 - 180 HP
|
Power HP
102 - 136 HP
|
|
Acceleration 0-100km/h
10.5 - 11.2 s
|
Acceleration 0-100km/h
11.1 - 13.2 s
|
|
Max Speed
-
|
Max Speed
-
|
|
Torque
260 - 400 Nm
|
Torque
205 - 300 Nm
|
|
Number of Cylinders
4
|
Number of Cylinders
3 - 4
|
|
Power kW
88 - 132 kW
|
Power kW
75 - 100 kW
|
|
Engine capacity
1,499 - 2,197 cm3
|
Engine capacity
1,199 - 1,499 cm3
|
General |
|
|---|---|
|
Model Year
2,024 - 2,026
|
Model Year
2,025 - 2,026
|
|
CO2 Efficiency Class
A, F
|
CO2 Efficiency Class
A, E
|
|
Brand
Fiat
|
Brand
Toyota
|
Deutschland
France
Nederland
Great Britain
Sverige
Danmark
Suomi
Italia
Polska
Česko
España